Active Melody

Learn to play blues guitar.

  • Log In
  • Weekly Lessons
  • Take The Tour
  • Forum
  • Hear From Our Members
  • Membership Sign Up

October 2026 Challenge – Richard G

Home › Forums › Active Melody Member Challenge Response Submissions › October 2026 Challenge – Richard G

  • This topic has 21 replies, 21 voices, and was last updated 5 hours, 11 minutes ago by Laurel C.
Viewing 20 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • November 13, 2026 at 3:43 am #426111
      Richard G
      Participant

        Here’s my ‘Then and Now’ Challenge

        I recorded and posted this first ‘St James Infirmary’ back in July 2018, it was one of Brian’s first lessons on a song which was in the Public Domain.
        As a blues classic, I had to learn and play it, however I found it to be quite difficult and one of the hardest lessons I’d tackled at that time. As you can see from this video posted 8 years ago, several occurrences of hesitation, mis-timing and fumbles from me. The audio level is also low so a tweak on your volume might help.

        Moving on, I’ve learnt a lot from watching my recordings over the years and have hopefully been able to make improvements wherever possible. Over time I’ve also added a few alternative sequences to St James Infirmary in the hope of filling out the piece and improving the overall performance. Here’s hoping you can see a difference in this latest version.

        Richard

        St. James Infirmary – 2018

        St. James Infirmary – 2026

        • This topic was modified 3 days, 3 hours ago by Richard G.
      • November 13, 2026 at 4:00 am #426115
        wannaplayblues
        Participant

          Wow – you were already so good back in 2018!!!

          That said, you certainly seem more confident in your playing now and the timing seems more accurate, yet relaxed (if that makes sense).

          Also, seems like your audio recording has improved – is that a reverb i can hear? However you recorded it, it sounds more “professionally” finished/polished.

          "I hear you talkin' son, but you 'aint sayin' nothin'" - Will McFarlane quoting Muddy Waters hearing a really fast guitar player

        • November 13, 2026 at 4:32 am #426119
          Dieter
          Participant

            Yes, that’s really challenging material—played excellently, with a steady build-up.

            Dieter

          • November 13, 2026 at 5:29 am #426123
            charjo
            Moderator

              I started listening to the first one believing it was the more recent version, thinking, “This is awesome”. The second is definitely more fluid and complex. I’m going to have to start referring to you as Tommy G.
              John

            • November 13, 2026 at 5:54 am #426139
              Guido
              Participant

                8 years ago it was already a very good rendition, but your today’s rendition has improved a lot, much more fluent and expressive, masterfully played. And then the recording quality has dramatically improved!

                A very enjoyable and beautiful rendition of one of my favourite minor blues songs, Richard!

                Guido

                • This reply was modified 3 days, 1 hour ago by Guido.
              • November 13, 2026 at 5:57 am #426141
                John H
                Participant

                  Beautifully played, (both of them). I think the recording quality in the more recent version is better, less noise. I agree with John, the second version sounds a bit more advanced seamless. Well done, always a pleasure Richard. Is your Martin a D-35? Please let me know when you get a chance. Thank you.

                  John

                  • November 13, 2026 at 6:03 am #426146
                    Richard G
                    Participant

                      Many thanks for your kind comments John, yes it is a Martin D35. I bought it new 28 years ago in Las Vegas. I chose it over the iconic D28 as the D35 with its more slender bracing, had a slightly brighter tone.

                      Richard

                  • November 13, 2026 at 8:57 am #426167
                    Tremelow
                    Participant

                      Hi Richard, the first version was already good, only that I could detect a few unwarranted pauses here and there. This month’s contribution is clearly smoother. St. James Infirmary is a Blues classic for a good reason and you do it justice.

                    • November 13, 2026 at 9:33 am #426175
                      Michael Krailo
                      Participant

                        I did the same thing John did and thought the first one was the most recent. The new version is tighter and has a great recording sound quality to it, but you had some chops on the old version as well.

                        Root note patterns >>> CAGED shapes >>> TRIAD'S. Just put in the work and watch your guitar skills soar.

                      • November 13, 2026 at 11:25 am #426202
                        Michael L
                        Participant

                          Hi Richard, I enjoyed both versions, though I recognize the upgrades in the second. I always love your playing, smooth and polished and so musical.

                        • November 13, 2026 at 11:56 am #426212
                          Alan L
                          Participant

                            I agree the old one was already good! But cleaner technique and just seems more fluid and smooth on the new one. I love the lively upbeat pace of your version

                          • November 13, 2026 at 12:25 pm #426223
                            JoeD1
                            Participant

                              You were a darned good player 8 years ago but I can clearly hear the polish you’ve added to the newest version.

                              Joe

                              The sight of a touch, or the scent of a sound,
                              Or the strength of an Oak with roots deep in the ground.
                              --Graeme Edge

                            • November 13, 2026 at 10:11 pm #426274
                              Alan O
                              Participant

                                Hi Richard, both of these sound really good! The more recent one definitely sounds more fluid and expressive as others have said. Also, your recording quality has greatly improved.

                                Alan

                              • November 13, 2026 at 10:55 pm #426278
                                AndréM
                                Participant

                                  It was already good in 2018 but 2026 is more polished.
                                  Awesome difference.

                                  AndréM

                                  AndréM

                                • November 14, 2026 at 2:54 am #426301
                                  Manfred M
                                  Participant

                                    Both versions are absolutely fantastic, Richard. You were already a great guitarist back in 2018 , too.
                                    The new version, however, is a lot more laid-back and flows beautifully. The sound is also more prominent.
                                    You prove that it’s always possible to make something very good even better.

                                    Take the chance to meet your AM friends on Zoom.
                                    The next Meetup will take place in January 2027

                                    There will be a detailed announcement here in the forum a few weeks before.

                                    I look forward to meet you.
                                    Manfred

                                  • November 14, 2026 at 4:07 am #426311
                                    Martin W
                                    Participant

                                      Hi Richard , I think the first one is an excellent spring board to work off , you played that one so well , but the second one is overall much more refined and in the pocket and adding your own ideas just shows how you’ve progressed .
                                      The recording quality was a standout as well .

                                      Martin

                                    • November 14, 2026 at 10:42 am #426347
                                      Mike W
                                      Participant

                                        I would be delighted to play this as good as your first version, despite the couple of very minor hesitations. The later rendition is noticeably smoother and played at a great pace.

                                      • November 14, 2026 at 1:05 pm #426371
                                        JoLa
                                        Participant

                                          At first, I thought, “what could you possibly improve here?” after re-listening to the first version. But of course, there’s improvement in both your performance and the recording quality. I guess we all are learning how to improve our recording skills along with the string skills! I loved the bouncy rhythm of your latest rendition, as well as your own added lines, fitting in so well. You made this standard your own from the get-go, Richard. It only remotely reminds me of Brian’s version.

                                          🎸JoLa

                                        • November 14, 2026 at 3:28 pm #426384
                                          sciencefiction
                                          Participant

                                            Wow. That’s fantastic improvement over 8 years, Richard! Went from excellent to sublime! I hear you.
                                            Larry

                                          • November 14, 2026 at 3:40 pm #426388
                                            David H
                                            Participant

                                              Richard, simply amazing what you have done to an already excellent first version. I continue to be amazed and delighted with your postings. Thank you!

                                            • November 15, 2026 at 7:46 pm #426570
                                              Brian
                                              Keymaster

                                                Yeah Richard that was great! Incredible how far you’ve come as a player and even way better audio quality overall. I like the fingerstyle arrangement of St James, much more the way Chet might approach it. Beautiful playing my friend. You’ve earned an extra cup of tea 🙂

                                              • November 16, 2026 at 1:44 am #426583
                                                Laurel C
                                                Moderator

                                                  Haven’t heard ‘St James Infirmary’ played by a member for years so I was looking forward to just hearing it again… and twice. I thought the first one was great but when hearing the second one, I could hear the differences, the bounce in your playing, obviously the sound of the guitar just comes alive and your clockwork fingers just more refined like a bottle of wine. Cheers. Just proves even the best can keep on improving.

                                              • Author
                                                Posts
                                              Viewing 20 reply threads
                                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                              Log In

                                              Search Forums

                                              Quick Links

                                              • Latest posts
                                              • Most popular posts
                                              • Posts Freshness
                                              • Posts with most replies
                                              • My active posts
                                              • All my posts
                                              • Posts with my reply

                                              Links

                                              • Blog
                                              • Resources
                                              • About
                                              • Contact
                                              • FAQ
                                              • Refunds & Cancellations
                                              • Sitemap

                                              Recent Lessons

                                              Bluegrass licks… but make them Bluesy – Weekly Guitar Lesson – EP646

                                              These Pedal Steel Licks Are Hiding Inside Your Triads – Guitar Lesson – EP645

                                              Mix harmonies with the minor pentatonic scale to create a more melodic Blues – Guitar Lesson – ML153

                                              Contact

                                              For all support questions email: support@activemelody.com
                                              For all other inquires email: brian@activemelody.com
                                              • Facebook
                                              • Twitter
                                              • YouTube

                                              © 2026 · Active Melody. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

                                              Free Weekly Guitar Lessons

                                              Enter your email address below to have the weekly guitar lesson delivered to your email address. I take privacy very seriously and will not share your email address.

                                              • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

                                              Active MelodyLogo Header Menu
                                              • Weekly Lessons
                                              • Take The Tour
                                              • Forum
                                              • Hear From Our Members
                                              • Membership Sign Up
                                              • Log In

                                              Insert/edit link

                                              Enter the destination URL

                                              Or link to existing content

                                                No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.