Active Melody

Learn to play blues guitar.

  • Log In
  • Weekly Lessons
  • Take The Tour
  • Forum
  • Hear From Our Members
  • Membership Sign Up

Our Blues Roots: “Love In Vain” (originally titled “Love In Vain Blues”)

Home › Forums › Our Blues Roots – The History of the Blues › Our Blues Roots: “Love In Vain” (originally titled “Love In Vain Blues”)

Tagged: #OurBluesRoots #LoveInVain #RobertJohnson #RollingStones

  • This topic has 5 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 1 month ago by Don D..
Viewing 5 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • September 15, 2016 at 6:16 pm #50826
      Don D.
      Moderator

        To say Robert Johnson was extremely talented is an understatement, he seems to have been a musical genius, but another major aspect of his enduring appeal is his sad and mysterious 1939 death by poison, and the myth that he “sold his soul to the Devil” in return for his amazing musical skills.

        Johnny Shines, Robert Junior Lockwood (the “Junior” in his name is because he was Robert Johnson’s stepson, but the two weren’t all that much different ages), Sonny Boy Williamson II (Rice Miller), Elmore James, among his friends and peers, all outlived him by many years. I was surprised to learn that Hound Dog Taylor ran with the same crowd (although he may never have hung out with Robert Johnson, he seemed much younger to me).

        * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

        There’s a lot of interesting information about “Love In Vain” at Wikipedia. One thing is kind of strange, although it mentions the woman who inspired it, it only gives her first name. She was Willie Mae Powell.

        One of the Wiki authors mentions that R.J. borrowed the melody from Leroy Carr’s “(In The Evening) When The Sun Goes Down” (what did we do before just about every fact was correlated with just about every other?).

        Just because, here’s Big Bill Broonzy’s “When The Sun Goes Down.”

        Here’s take 1 of what Robert Johnson recorded in Dallas on Sunday, June 20, 1937 (from the remastered 2011 centennial release)

        Here’s take 2 (if you’ve never heard these remasters, you’ve never really heard Robert Johnson sound as good as possible).

        Here’s a YouTube playlist containing the two songs and some others.

        Here’s the Rolling Stones’ cover from Let It Bleed (the last album with Brian Jones and the first with Mick Taylor). They first credited either “traditional” or Woody Payne, but after a lawsuit, Robert Johnson was credited and his heirs were paid. It looks like it was more oversight than malice in the first place on the Stones’ part. Recorded between November 1968 and November 1969, it was the second song on side 1 of Let It Bleed, released on Friday, December 5, 1969. The Wikipedia article for the album mentions that Mick Jagger asked artist M.C. Escher to design a cover for the album but he declined.

        Here’s their cover from the live Get Yer Ya-Ya’s Out! The Rolling Stones in Concert (recorded Wednesday, November 26, 1969, Baltimore [rest of the record was recorded at Madison Square Garden on the next two days], released September 4, 1970).

        The Faces, live (1972)

        Peter Green Splinter Group from The Robert Johnson Songbook (1998)

        Eric Clapton from Me and Mr. Johnson (2004)

        Keb’ Mo’ on Legends of Jazz with Ramsey Lewis “Roots: The Blues Episode” (2006)

        I had to do this in a hurry. I’ll be back with some additional versions.

        Don D.

      • September 16, 2016 at 10:44 am #50865
        Billy
        Participant

          I forgot just how good the Faces were and I forgot just how good Ronnie is on that guitar of his, that was a superb version of RJ’s song Love in Vain and now I am going to have to dig through Faces songs to see what other gems I have forgot over the years..

          Thanks for that Don

          ..Billy..

        • September 16, 2016 at 11:14 am #50866
          Maradonagol
          Participant

            @billy M
            @don d.

            Second that Billy….that was awesome…..thanks Don….given this fantastic post….no need for a new lesson friday today!! Loved the Clapton version too…..a song to go back and learn….

            have a great weekend…

            Roberto

          • September 16, 2016 at 11:21 am #50867
            Don D.
            Moderator

              My very favorite cut with Rod Stewart was an early one with Aynsley Dunbar’s group of the moment, Peter Green on guitar, Jack Bruce on bass doing Buddy Guy’s “Stone Crazy.” It’s said to be the only recording by that lineup. I’ve posted it here so if you search the forum, it should turn up.

              This isn’t meant to be a substitute for New Lesson Friday. Have a nice weekend!

              Don D.

            • September 16, 2016 at 11:51 am #50868
              Billy
              Participant

                Couldn’t find that which you mention Don, I did however come across this from Buddy and Junior..
                I think there must be at least 5 songs that come to mind with the opening riff or a similar opening riff…
                I think I am falling in love with Buddy Guy’s music, it is rocking me off my chair….

                ..Billy..

              • September 16, 2016 at 1:30 pm #50872
                Don D.
                Moderator

                  The one you found is better but here’s the one I mentioned, 1965, I think.
                  https://www.youtube.com/shared?ci=YGTZk4wQWG0

                  Don D.

              • Author
                Posts
              Viewing 5 reply threads
              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
              Log In

              Search Forums

              Quick Links

              • Latest posts
              • Most popular posts
              • Posts Freshness
              • Posts with most replies
              • My active posts
              • All my posts
              • Posts with my reply

              Links

              • Blog
              • Resources
              • About
              • Contact
              • FAQ
              • Refunds & Cancellations
              • Sitemap

              Recent Lessons

              Blues lead over a jam track with STOPS! – Fill the space when the band stops – Guitar Lesson – EP622

              Play an entire Blues lead in 1 position of the fretboard (E shape from CAGED) Guitar Lesson EP621

              Jamming by yourself on guitar – Bluegrass style! – Guitar Lesson – EP620

              Contact

              For all support questions email: support@activemelody.com
              For all other inquires email: brian@activemelody.com
              • Facebook
              • Twitter
              • YouTube

              © 2025 · Active Melody. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

              Free Weekly Guitar Lessons

              Enter your email address below to have the weekly guitar lesson delivered to your email address. I take privacy very seriously and will not share your email address.

              • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

              Active MelodyLogo Header Menu
              • Weekly Lessons
              • Take The Tour
              • Forum
              • Hear From Our Members
              • Membership Sign Up
              • Log In

              Insert/edit link

              Enter the destination URL

              Or link to existing content

                No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.