Active Melody

Learn to play blues guitar.

  • Log In
  • Weekly Lessons
  • Take The Tour
  • Forum
  • Hear From Our Members
  • Membership Sign Up

These tone test results didn’t surprise me

Home › Forums › Discuss Your Gear › These tone test results didn’t surprise me

  • This topic has 4 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 2 months, 1 week ago by sunjamr.
Viewing 3 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • September 26, 2025 at 9:22 am #400895
      GnLguy
      Participant

        A $5k PRS was the clear loser in this test and it dispelled the hype of amazing tone woods etc being superior.

        The test was between a $5k PRS McCarty Ten Top, a PRS SE built by Cort in Indonesia and a $270 Harley Benton
        The people judging the results were popular hosts of YT channels and some industry people
        My condolences to Paul Reed Smith, his expensive guitar didn’t prove to be superior.

      • September 26, 2025 at 2:30 pm #400901
        sunjamr
        Participant

          The hype about tonewood reminds me of a fairytale by Hans Christian Andersen called “The Emperor’s New Clothes”. Everyone was conned into believing the Emperor was wearing a fine new set of clothes as he rode through the streets of the city, but finally a little kid blurted out “Hey, the Emperor is naked!”

          Sunjamr Steve

          • September 26, 2025 at 3:49 pm #400903
            GnLguy
            Participant

              Good analogy Steve

              If a person wants a guitar from a custom shop and can afford it, go for it – more power to them. But when the sound comes out of the speakers, most listeners won’t be able to tell the difference

              My favorite Brit player, Alvin Lee, used a late 50’s ES-335, affectionately named Big Red. Being concerned with the possibility of theft, Alvin placed Red in his vault and began using signature models of Red made by Tokai – no difference his sound.
              Alvin didn’t use effects, guitar straight into the amp and his sound was controlled with his volume and tone controls. A well made 335 copy with good pickups gave Alvin everything he needed

              In this video at the 13:50 mark, Rhett Shull, is amazed how a current model Epiphone Les Paul 1960 Standard compares to a ’60 Les Paul…

          • September 26, 2025 at 4:57 pm #400904
            San Luis Rey
            Participant

              Love it Keith. Sea monkeys or Mahogany, It doesn’t matter. Take any average guitar, give it a great setup and you are in business my friend.

              Mike

            • September 26, 2025 at 5:30 pm #400907
              sunjamr
              Participant

                And don’t forget Jim Lill, who has done a lot of testing to learn the truth about where tone comes from:

                Sunjamr Steve

            • Author
              Posts
            Viewing 3 reply threads
            • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
            Log In

            Search Forums

            Quick Links

            • Latest posts
            • Most popular posts
            • Posts Freshness
            • Posts with most replies
            • My active posts
            • All my posts
            • Posts with my reply

            Links

            • Blog
            • Resources
            • About
            • Contact
            • FAQ
            • Refunds & Cancellations
            • Sitemap

            Recent Lessons

            Ragtime solo Blues Guitar – no jam track needed! – Learn how to create one – Guitar Lesson – EP624

            Use chords to guide your lead and show you where to find harmonies – Guitar Lesson – EP623

            Blues lead over a jam track with STOPS! – Fill the space when the band stops – Guitar Lesson – EP622

            Contact

            For all support questions email: support@activemelody.com
            For all other inquires email: brian@activemelody.com
            • Facebook
            • Twitter
            • YouTube

            © 2025 · Active Melody. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use

            Free Weekly Guitar Lessons

            Enter your email address below to have the weekly guitar lesson delivered to your email address. I take privacy very seriously and will not share your email address.

            • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

            Active MelodyLogo Header Menu
            • Weekly Lessons
            • Take The Tour
            • Forum
            • Hear From Our Members
            • Membership Sign Up
            • Log In

            Insert/edit link

            Enter the destination URL

            Or link to existing content

              No search term specified. Showing recent items. Search or use up and down arrow keys to select an item.